Short answer: with 2026's average employer plans, an HSA-eligible high-deductible plan (HDHP) comes out cheaper than a PPO for a single person at almost every level of medical spending, if you fund the HSA: about $2,080 a year cheaper for a healthy year and still about $580 cheaper in a year that hits the out-of-pocket maximum. If you will not put money into the HSA, the PPO wins once your care costs more than about $2,700 a year. The difference is the HSA's tax break, worth about $1,120 on a full 2027 contribution in the 22% bracket.
Open enrollment for 2027 benefits is closing at most employers this month, and for many people the biggest choice on the form is the plan itself. The usual advice, "healthy people take the HDHP, people who use care take the PPO", ignores the HSA. This guide runs the numbers for five levels of medical spending using KFF's 2026 employer survey averages and the IRS's 2027 HSA limits, and shows when the advice is right.
Who this is for: employees choosing between an HSA-eligible plan and a PPO (or HMO) for 2027, self-only coverage first, with notes for families. What it does not cover: Marketplace plans (see ACA premiums for 2027), Medicare, and HMOs with narrow networks, whose trade-off is about doctors more than dollars. This is general information, not financial or medical advice: your own plan's numbers decide it.
The two plansWhat you are comparing
Pay more every month, less when you need care
Higher premium. Lower deductible, often copays for visits and prescriptions before the deductible. No HSA. KFF 2026 average single deductible in PPOs: $1,446.
Pay less every month, more up front when you need care
Lower premium. Deductible of at least $1,750 (self-only) in 2027; KFF 2026 average in HSA-qualified plans: $2,912. You can contribute up to $4,500 to an HSA in 2027, pre-tax, and keep it for life.
Three numbers decide which plan costs less in a given year: the premium gap you pay, the out-of-pocket costs at your level of care, and the HSA money: what your employer puts in plus the tax you save on what you put in.
The 2027 limitsWhat the IRS sets
For 2027, an HDHP must have a deductible of at least $1,750 for self-only coverage or $3,500 for a family, and an out-of-pocket maximum no higher than $8,700 or $17,400. HSA contributions are capped at $4,500 self-only and $9,000 family, plus $1,000 at 55 or older, employer money included (IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24). The full limit table, and how a health FSA compares, is in HSA vs FSA for 2027.
What employers chargeKFF's 2026 averages
KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey puts the average worker's share of the premium at $1,672 a year for single coverage and $7,471 for family coverage. In HSA-qualified plans it is lower, $1,497 single and $6,211 family, and employers that pair the plan with an HSA put in an average $713 for single coverage and $1,346 for family coverage, counting workers who get nothing (KFF, 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey).
Source: KFF 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey; CalculatorAI estimate for the non-HSA premium; calculatorai.app
Share / download
KFF reports the overall average and the HSA-plan average; the $1,743 for other plans is our estimate from those two numbers and the 29% of workers enrolled in HSA plans. For family coverage the same method gives about $7,986, a gap of roughly $1,775 a year.
The comparisonFive levels of medical spending
The model: single coverage, the premiums and deductibles above, 20% coinsurance after the deductible, an out-of-pocket maximum of $4,500 for the PPO and $6,000 for the HDHP (assumptions within the legal limits), the $713 employer HSA deposit, and the employee contributing the rest of the $4,500 limit ($3,787) through payroll. That contribution avoids federal income tax at 22% and payroll tax at 7.65%, about $1,123. "Net cost" is what the year costs you: premiums plus out-of-pocket, minus the employer's HSA money and your tax saving. Money you put in the HSA and do not spend stays yours.
$500 (a checkup and a prescription)
- PPO
- $2,243
- HDHP + funded HSA
- $161
- HDHP saves
- $2,082
$2,000
- PPO
- $3,300
- HDHP + funded HSA
- $1,661
- HDHP saves
- $1,639
$5,000
- PPO
- $3,900
- HDHP + funded HSA
- $2,991
- HDHP saves
- $910
$15,000 (a surgery)
- PPO
- $5,900
- HDHP + funded HSA
- $4,991
- HDHP saves
- $910
$40,000 (out-of-pocket max)
- PPO
- $6,243
- HDHP + funded HSA
- $5,661
- HDHP saves
- $582
| Medical spending (allowed amount) | PPO | HDHP + funded HSA | HDHP saves |
|---|---|---|---|
| $500 (a checkup and a prescription) | $2,243 | $161 | $2,082 |
| $2,000 | $3,300 | $1,661 | $1,639 |
| $5,000 | $3,900 | $2,991 | $910 |
| $15,000 (a surgery) | $5,900 | $4,991 | $910 |
| $40,000 (out-of-pocket max) | $6,243 | $5,661 | $582 |
Source: drafts/hdhp-vs-ppo-2027-numbers.mjs; KFF 2026; IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24; CalculatorAI analysis · calculatorai.app
Share / download
The HDHP wins in every row, because the premium saving, the employer deposit and the tax break together (about $2,080) are larger than the extra out-of-pocket exposure. That is the headline the "healthy people only" rule misses.
Without the HSAWhen the PPO wins
Take the tax break away, and the answer flips for anyone who uses much care:
$500
- PPO
- $2,243
- HDHP, empty HSA
- $1,284
- Cheaper plan
- HDHP by $959
$2,000
- PPO
- $3,300
- HDHP, empty HSA
- $2,784
- Cheaper plan
- HDHP by $516
$5,000
- PPO
- $3,900
- HDHP, empty HSA
- $4,114
- Cheaper plan
- PPO by $213
$15,000
- PPO
- $5,900
- HDHP, empty HSA
- $6,114
- Cheaper plan
- PPO by $213
$40,000
- PPO
- $6,243
- HDHP, empty HSA
- $6,784
- Cheaper plan
- PPO by $541
| Medical spending | PPO | HDHP, empty HSA | Cheaper plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| $500 | $2,243 | $1,284 | HDHP by $959 |
| $2,000 | $3,300 | $2,784 | HDHP by $516 |
| $5,000 | $3,900 | $4,114 | PPO by $213 |
| $15,000 | $5,900 | $6,114 | PPO by $213 |
| $40,000 | $6,243 | $6,784 | PPO by $541 |
Source: drafts/hdhp-vs-ppo-2027-numbers.mjs; CalculatorAI analysis · calculatorai.app
Share / download
With an empty HSA the break-even is about $2,700 of medical spending a year. Above that, the PPO's lower deductible and lower out-of-pocket maximum are worth more than the premium saving. So the real rule is: pick the HDHP only if you will fund the HSA, or if you are confident your care will stay under a couple of thousand dollars.
FamiliesSame logic, bigger numbers
For family coverage the premium gap in KFF's averages is about $1,775 a year, the employer HSA deposit averages $1,346, and the 2027 HSA limit is $9,000, worth about $2,270 in tax at the same rates if fully funded after the employer's share. Family deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums are roughly double, so the HDHP's worst case is larger too. A family that expects a baby, a planned surgery or regular specialist care should run its own numbers with its plan's real deductible and out-of-pocket maximum; one that is mostly healthy and can fund the HSA usually comes out ahead with the HDHP by more than a single person does.
Your own numbersFour lines from the benefits portal
Premium per paycheck, both plans
Multiply by your pay periods for the yearly gap.
Deductible and out-of-pocket maximum
For both plans, in-network, for your coverage tier.
Employer HSA contribution
Some employers deposit it all in January, others per paycheck; some match.
What you can afford to put in the HSA
Every dollar through payroll avoids income and payroll tax. The Paycheck Calculator shows what a pre-tax deduction does to take-home pay.
Then work out last year's medical spending from your insurer's claims history, add anything you know is coming, and compare the two plans at that level and at the out-of-pocket maximum. The Paycheck Calculator turns the HSA contribution into a per-paycheck number, which is what you will actually feel.
Where these numbers come from
- Employer averages: KFF 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey (October 22, 2026): worker premium contribution $1,672 single / $7,471 family overall and $1,497 / $6,211 in HSA-qualified plans; average single deductible $1,446 in PPOs and $2,912 in HSA-qualified plans; average employer HSA contribution $713 single / $1,346 family including workers who get none; 29% of covered workers in HSA-qualified plans, 50% in PPOs.
- Our estimate: the non-HSA worker premium ($1,743 single, $7,986 family) backs out the HSA-plan average from the overall average using the 29% enrollment share. KFF's PPO-only worker contribution sits in a figure we could not read as text; the share is for all covered workers, not each tier, so treat the gap as approximate.
- 2027 limits: IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24 (HSA $4,500 / $9,000, HDHP minimum deductible $1,750 / $3,500, out-of-pocket maximum $8,700 / $17,400).
- Assumptions: 20% coinsurance after the deductible; out-of-pocket maximums of $4,500 (PPO) and $6,000 (HDHP); 22% federal bracket plus 7.65% payroll tax on HSA contributions made through a cafeteria plan; no state income tax. Copays that many PPOs charge before the deductible are not modeled, which makes the PPO look slightly more expensive at low spending than it may be. Arithmetic in
drafts/hdhp-vs-ppo-2027-numbers.mjs.
FAQFrequently asked questions
Is an HDHP or a PPO better for 2027?
With 2026's average employer plans, the HSA-eligible HDHP is cheaper for a single person at every level of medical spending if you fund the HSA, by about $580 to $2,080 a year in our model. If you will not contribute to the HSA, the PPO is cheaper once your medical spending passes about $2,700 a year.
What is the HSA contribution limit for 2027?
$4,500 for self-only coverage and $9,000 for family coverage, plus a $1,000 catch-up from age 55. Employer contributions count toward the limit.
What is the minimum deductible for an HDHP in 2027?
$1,750 for self-only coverage and $3,500 for family coverage, with an out-of-pocket maximum of no more than $8,700 and $17,400 (IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24).
How much does the average employee pay for health insurance in 2026?
$1,672 a year for single coverage and $7,471 for family coverage, according to KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey. In HSA-qualified plans it is $1,497 and $6,211.
Who should not pick a high-deductible plan?
Someone who cannot cover the deductible from savings, will not contribute to the HSA, and expects more than a few thousand dollars of care in the year. For that person the PPO's lower out-of-pocket costs usually outweigh the premium saving.
The decision rule
Fund it or skip it. An HDHP with a funded HSA beat the average PPO in every scenario we ran, by about $2,080 in a light year and $580 in a worst year. An HDHP with an empty HSA is a bet that you will stay healthy, and it loses above about $2,700 of care. Before the enrollment window closes, put both plans' four numbers side by side and check what the HSA contribution does to your take-home pay in the Paycheck Calculator.






